BMI doesn't seem right?

(4 replies)

by arielmyers

about 1 year ago

Viewed 531 times

Okay, I weigh 143 lbs, I'm 4'2", and my waist is 33", my hips are 41". It says I'm Obese, and I clearly know I'm not Obese! I do have fat in my midsection, but not a whole bunch, and I have a lot of muscle, especially in my legs. I'm wondering why it says Obese, I know I'm not Obese, I think it's just that extra fat around my midsection and muscle on my legs. It just doesn't seem right!

Post A Reply

jfenn replied about 1 year ago:

Are you sure that you put all the correct measurements into the calculator?

Quote Flag for abuse
arielmyers replied about 1 year ago:

Yes, they are all the correct measurements, I've checked multiple times!

Quote Flag for abuse
livierah replied 9 months ago:

the latest research shows that bmi is boggers, it doesn't take muscle into consideration. muscle weighs more than fat, so if you look very healthy and you weigh more because of muscle then bmi shows you overweight or obese, so don't rely on bmi so much, it's not very accurate or reliable. so if you are happy with yourself, that's all that really counts and you are healthy

Quote Flag for abuse
arielmyers replied 9 months ago:

“the latest research shows that bmi is boggers, it doesn't take muscle into consideration. muscle weighs more than fat, so if you look very healthy and you weigh more because of muscle then bmi shows you overweight or obese, so don't rely on bmi so much, it's not very accurate or reliable. so if you are happy with yourself, that's all that really counts and you are healthy”
by: livierah

thanks!

Quote Flag for abuse