Netflix’s To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before was definitely one of the cutest romcoms we’ve seen in a while… and pretty much the world agreed. Thankfully, the movie was based off of Jenny Han’s book series of the same name, meaning there was more than one movie to come. And on Feb. 12 our dreams came true when the sequel, P.S. I Still Love You, premiered on Netflix.

The movie highlights Lara Jean and Peter Kavinsky trying to figure out their new relationship and romance, all while handling various obstacles being thrown in their way. This movie is different in that it features a sort of love triangle when Lara Jean’s childhood best friend, John Ambrose, comes back to town after getting one of her love letters. To find out what happens, you’ll obviously have to watch the movie. But in the meanwhile, you can enjoy this adorable and hilarious video from Pop Sugar of Lana Condor, who plays Lara Jean, and Jordan Fisher, who plays John Ambrose, creating their own love letter with Mad Libs. And you can’t go wrong with a game of romantic Mad Libs, right?

The pair filled in the blanks of the game with information like favorite Netflix character (John Ambrose said Michael Scott) and last place you ate dinner (Lana said her bed). Some of the other hilarious answers included a story of when Lana ate a bunch of hot spicy chicken wings and projectile vomited into an elevator full of people, including her team.

Although the answers were random and hilarious, the love letter at the end was admittedly pretty cute. To find out what was said, go on and watch the video for yourself: