When choosing the right shade for you, the key is to think of the color wheel. “The focus isn’t on the makeup color you’re seeing,” makeup artist Stephen Dimmick reminds us. “It’s really about how it’ll make your eye color look.” If you use a makeup shade that’s complementary to the color of your eyes, you peepers will truly look brighter and more vibrant. Stick to bold hues on the top lid and lashes—it’ll create a lifted look that’ll make you look livelier and more youthful.
MORE: The Best New Eye Makeup For Your Eye Color